DeleteMe vs Incogni vs Optery shown as an advisor desk with a report folder, a conveyor sending requests to broker tiles, and a magnifier over a profile.

DeleteMe vs Incogni vs Optery: Best Data Removal Services for Privacy-Conscious Freelancers

Your name, address, phone number, and relatives can sit on dozens of people-search sites, and freelancers who publish under their own name are easy to find. Removing those listings by hand takes hours and has to be repeated, because brokers re-list data. That is why people pay for removal services, and why the choice between DeleteMe vs Incogni vs Optery matters.

All three submit removal requests to data brokers on your behalf. DeleteMe adds human-handled custom requests, Incogni automates the most sites for the lowest price, and Optery offers a free scan with screenshot proof. None of them guarantees results, and independent testing is thin.

I reviewed DeleteMe vs Incogni vs Optery for 30 days, running Optery’s free scan, reading each service’s plan terms and sample reports, and comparing them against Consumer Reports’ independent study. Here is the honest comparison. Two catches to know first: in that 2024 study, DeleteMe removed 27% of test listings and Optery’s top plan removed 68%, and Incogni was not tested at all.

How We Tested

I scored each service on five criteria, using the same freelancer profile throughout.

  1. Automated coverage. I compared how many sites each service handles on its own, not the headline broker counts.
  2. Independent evidence. I looked for third-party results, such as Consumer Reports’ study and audit reports.
  3. Price over 12 and 36 months. I priced one person on annual billing and flagged renewal and billing traps.
  4. Proof and reporting. I checked whether each service shows what it found and removed, and how often.
  5. Fit for freelancers and households. I looked at family plans, custom removals, and regional coverage.

I also considered that a business mailing address and domain WHOIS privacy reduce new exposure that none of these services can remove. Securing online privacy also involves using one of the best privacy browsers for bloggers to prevent active data collection.

DeleteMe Review: Human-Assisted Removal at a Premium Price

  • Free plan: None; no free trial, and the refund window is short (about 7 days after the first report)
  • Starting price: $129 a year for one person (annual billing only)
  • Best plan for most users: Standard, one person
  • Platforms: Web
  • Affiliate program: None confirmed

DeleteMe is a subscription service that removes your personal data from people-search sites and data brokers. It lists 969 to 976 brokers, but its standard plan automates roughly 86 to 101 of them and handles the rest through custom removal requests. It sends a privacy report every quarter. Freelancers securing their business assets should also evaluate the best WordPress security plugins to protect personal site data.

What DeleteMe does best

DeleteMe is the most hands-on of the three. A privacy advisor handles opt-outs and custom requests, and plans include phone and email support. You get a first report within about seven days and a PDF report every quarter.

Couple and family plans are straightforward: $229 for two people and $329 for up to four. Two-year options cost $209, $349, and $499. Custom removals, 40 a year and 60 on Premium, let you target sites outside the automated list.

Where DeleteMe falls short

The headline number is misleading. DeleteMe advertises 969 to 976 brokers, but standard plans automate about 86 to 101. The rest depend on 40 custom removal requests a year, so you must choose which sites to chase.

In Consumer Reports’ 2024 study, DeleteMe removed 27% of test listings after four months, against 68% for Optery’s top plan. That fieldwork is two years old and the DeleteMe group was small, but it is the only independent result. There is no monthly billing or free trial, and plans renew at the regular price.

Funnel from DeleteMe’s 969 to 976 listed brokers to about 86 to 101 automated and 40 custom removals a year, with its 27% test result.

DeleteMe pricing

Plan1-year price2-year pricePeopleNotes
Standard, one person$129$2091About 86 to 101 automated sites, 40 custom removals a year, quarterly reports
Standard, couple$229$3492Same features as one person
Standard, family$329$499Up to 4Same features as one person
Premium, one person$180Not listed1About 15 more sites, 60 custom removals, reports every two months
BusinessCustomCustomCustomQuote only

DeleteMe: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Human-handled custom removals and phone support
  • Quarterly PDF reports
  • Couple and family plans up to four people
  • Established US coverage

Cons:

  • Only 27% removal in Consumer Reports’ 2024 study
  • Standard plans automate about 86 to 101 sites despite 969 to 976 listed
  • No monthly billing, free trial, or long refund window
  • Highest price for one person of the three

Rating: 3.7 / 5, attentive service, but the lowest tested result and the highest price.

Incogni Review: The Cheapest Broad Automation

  • Free plan: None; check refund terms at signup
  • Starting price: $7.99 a month billed annually ($95.88 a year), or $15.98 monthly
  • Best plan for most users: Standard for one person; Unlimited if you need custom removals
  • Platforms: Web
  • Affiliate program: None confirmed

Incogni is an automated removal service owned by Surfshark. It sends opt-out requests to 420+ data brokers across the US, UK, EU, Canada, and other regions, repeats them on a schedule, and shows each request’s status in a dashboard. A Deloitte limited-assurance report supports its claim that it contacts those brokers.

What Incogni does best

Incogni is the cheapest of the three for broad automated coverage. Standard costs $95.88 a year and automates 420+ brokers, with recurring requests and no per-site decisions for you to make. It also covers more regions than DeleteMe, which is US-focused.

Independent checks exist, though they are thinner than a removal-rate test. Deloitte’s report confirms the 420+ broker outreach, and Gizmodo’s four-month test saw 107 requests sent to 44 brokers, 102 of them closed, and placement on 17 suppression lists. Family plans cover up to five people from $191.88 a year.

Where Incogni falls short

Incogni was not in Consumer Reports’ study, so it has no independent removal rate. Custom removals, which target sites outside the 420+ list, require Unlimited at $179.88 a year. Standard includes none.

Monthly billing doubles the price, from $7.99 to $15.98, so annual billing is the only reasonable option. Some reviews still quote Unlimited at $17.99 a month, but Incogni now lists $14.99 on annual billing. A US-only Protect tier that adds identity-theft insurance costs $20.74 a month on annual billing.

Four-step staircase of Incogni plans from Standard at $95.88 a year to Family Unlimited at $275.88, with custom removals only on Unlimited tiers.

Incogni pricing

PlanMonthly billingAnnual billingPeopleCustom removals
Standard$15.98$95.88 a year ($7.99 a month)1No
Unlimited$29.98$179.88 a year ($14.99 a month)1Unlimited
Family$31.98$191.88 a year ($15.99 a month)Up to 5No
Family Unlimited$45.98$275.88 a year ($22.99 a month)Up to 5Unlimited

Incogni: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Automates 420+ brokers on the Standard plan
  • Lowest annual price for broad coverage
  • Deloitte limited-assurance report
  • Family plans for up to five people

Cons:

  • Not tested in Consumer Reports’ study
  • Custom removals need the Unlimited plan
  • Monthly billing doubles the price
  • No free plan

Rating: 4.3 / 5, the cheapest broad automation, without an independent removal rate.

Optery Review: The Best Free Scan and the Best Tested Score on Its Top Plan

  • Free plan: Yes (Basic); quarterly scans, an exposure report, and self-service opt-out instructions
  • Starting price: Core at $39 a year ($3.99 monthly); Ultimate at $249 a year
  • Best plan for most users: Free Basic to start; Ultimate for full coverage
  • Platforms: Web
  • Affiliate program: None confirmed

Optery is a data removal service that scans for exposed profiles, shows screenshots, and removes them. Free Basic gives you a scan and instructions for removing profiles yourself. Paid plans automate removal, with coverage that rises by tier: 367+ sites on Core, 545+ on Extended, and 641+ on Ultimate.

What Optery does best

Optery has the best proof and the only usable free plan. Free Basic scans for exposed profiles quarterly and returns a report with screenshots, so you can see your exposure before you pay. Extended and Ultimate send before-and-after removal reports with screenshots every 90 days.

It also has the best independent result. In Consumer Reports’ 2024 study, Optery’s Ultimate plan removed 68% of test listings after four months, the highest score of the services tested. Extended adds human-assisted opt-outs and unlimited name variations.

Where Optery falls short

Coverage depends on the tier, and the tested score belongs to the $249 Ultimate plan. Core, at $39 a year, covers fewer and more niche sites, and Extended limits custom removals. Optery sells individual plans only, so a family of four on Ultimate would pay about $996 a year.

Vendors count brokers differently. Optery’s coverage ranges from about 120 sites on Core without its Expanded Reach option to 367+ with it, so compare what is automated, not the headline number. One review says Optery’s reach excludes the EU and UK, so check availability if you live outside the US. Website owners focused on user data regulation should explore the best cookie consent and privacy compliance tools alongside data removal.

Four-step staircase of Optery tiers from Free Basic to Ultimate at $249 a year with 641+ sites, unlimited custom removals, and a 68% test result.

Optery pricing

PlanMonthly billingYearly billingAutomated coverageNotes
Free Basic$0$0None automatedQuarterly scans, exposure report with screenshots, opt-out instructions
Core$3.99$39 a year367+ sitesMonthly scans and opt-out progress reports
Extended$14.99$149 a year545+ sitesHuman-assisted opt-outs, unlimited name variations, removal reports every 90 days
Ultimate$24.99$249 a year641+ sitesHighest coverage, unlimited custom removals, the plan Consumer Reports tested

Optery: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Usable free plan with a screenshot exposure report
  • Highest independent score: 68% on Ultimate
  • Before-and-after removal screenshots on Extended and Ultimate
  • Core starts at $39 a year

Cons:

  • The tested score belongs to the $249 Ultimate plan
  • Coverage varies sharply by tier
  • Individual plans only, with no family bundle
  • Regional availability outside the US needs checking

Rating: 4.4 / 5, the best proof and the best tested score, on its most expensive plan.

Bubble chart of removal results against 36-month cost: manual opt-outs 70% at $0, Optery Ultimate 68% at $747, DeleteMe 27% at $387, Incogni untested.

Head-to-Head Comparison Table

FeatureDeleteMeIncogniOptery
Price for one person, annual billing$129$95.88 (Standard)$39 (Core), $149 (Extended), $249 (Ultimate)
Monthly billingNot offered$15.98$3.99, $14.99, or $24.99 by tier
Free plan or trialNone; about 7-day refund windowNoneFree Basic with scan
Automated coverageAbout 86 to 101 sites (969 to 976 listed)420+367+, 545+, or 641+ by tier
Custom removals40 a year (60 on Premium)Unlimited plan onlyUnlimited on Ultimate; limited on Extended
ReportsQuarterly PDF; every two months on PremiumDashboard statusScreenshots; removal reports every 90 days on Extended and Ultimate
Consumer Reports 2024 result27%Not tested68% (Ultimate)
Independent auditNone foundDeloitte limited-assurance reportNone found
Family optionCouple $229; family of four $329Up to five people from $191.88Individual plans only
RegionsUS-focusedUS, UK, EU, Canada, and moreCheck availability outside the US
36-month cost, one person, list price$387$287.64$117 (Core), $747 (Ultimate)
Affiliate programNone confirmedNone confirmedNone confirmed
Best forGuided help and phone supportCheapest broad automationProof and tested results
Our rating3.7 / 54.3 / 54.4 / 5

Which Should You Choose?

Choose Optery if you want evidence and proof. Start with the free scan, and move to Ultimate if the budget allows, since that is the tier with the best tested result.

Choose Incogni if you want the lowest price for broad automated coverage. Standard at $95.88 a year handles 420+ brokers, and Unlimited adds custom removals.

Choose DeleteMe if you want a human-guided service with phone support and cover a couple or a family. Accept that standard plans automate about 86 to 101 sites.

Skip all three if you have time to opt out yourself. Consumer Reports found manual opt-outs removed 70% of listings within a week, more than any paid service. Optery’s free plan gives you the scan and instructions to do it.

Compare list prices over three years, not the first-year price. One person pays $387 for DeleteMe, $287.64 for Incogni Standard, and $747 for Optery Ultimate, assuming renewals at list price. These services cannot remove domain WHOIS records or business filings, so consider the best virtual mailbox services in 2026 to keep home addresses off public filings.

Decision flowchart for choosing a data removal service: proof to Optery, lowest price to Incogni, human help to DeleteMe, time to opt out yourself.

Our Recommendations

  • Freelancer on a budget who wants to start: Run Optery’s free scan, then choose Incogni Standard at $95.88 a year or opt out manually.
  • Freelancer whose home address is public: Optery Ultimate for proof of removal, or Incogni Unlimited at $179.88 a year for custom removals.
  • Couple or household: Incogni Family at $191.88 a year for up to five people, or DeleteMe’s couple plan at $229 for two.
  • Freelancer outside the US: Incogni, which lists UK, EU, and Canada coverage.
  • Buyer who wants evidence over price: Optery Ultimate at $249 a year, with the best independent result.

Final Verdict

For most readers comparing DeleteMe vs Incogni vs Optery, Optery is the winner. It offers a free scan, screenshot proof, and the best independent result, though on its $249 plan. Incogni is the best price for broad automation, and DeleteMe suits people who want human help and accept lower coverage.

  • Optery: 4.4 / 5, the best proof and the best tested score, on its most expensive plan.
  • Incogni: 4.3 / 5, the cheapest broad automation, without an independent removal rate.
  • DeleteMe: 3.7 / 5, attentive service, but the lowest tested result and the highest price.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best data removal service for freelancers?

Optery is the best fit for most freelancers who want proof, because its free plan shows your exposure and its Ultimate plan scored 68% in Consumer Reports’ 2024 test. Incogni is the cheapest broad option at $95.88 a year. DeleteMe suits people who want phone support and human-handled custom requests.

Do data removal services work?

Partly. Consumer Reports’ 2024 study of seven services found they reduced exposure and saved time, but only 35% of the personal data they found stayed off after four months. Optery’s top plan reached 68%, EasyOptOuts 65%, and DeleteMe 27%. Manual opt-outs reached 70%, so no service is a guarantee.

How much does DeleteMe cost?

DeleteMe costs $129 a year for one person, $229 for two, and $329 for up to four, with two-year plans at $209, $349, and $499. Premium costs $180 a year for one person. It offers no monthly billing or free trial, and plans renew automatically at the regular price. Standard plans include 40 custom removals a year.

How much does Incogni cost?

Incogni Standard costs $95.88 a year ($7.99 a month) or $15.98 monthly. Unlimited, which adds custom removals, costs $179.88 a year. Family plans for up to five people cost $191.88 a year, or $275.88 with custom removals. Monthly billing doubles the cost, so choose annual billing unless you need only a month.

Is Optery free?

Yes, partly. Optery’s Free Basic plan scans for exposed profiles quarterly and returns an exposure report with screenshots, plus instructions for removing profiles yourself. It does not automate removals. Paid plans start at $39 a year for Core, $149 for Extended, and $249 for Ultimate, which has the broadest coverage.

Was Incogni tested by Consumer Reports?

No. Consumer Reports’ 2024 study tested Confidently, DeleteMe, EasyOptOuts, IDX, Kanary, Optery, and ReputationDefender, plus people who opted out themselves. Incogni was not included, so it has no independent removal rate from that study. Deloitte’s limited-assurance report confirms Incogni contacts 420+ brokers and repeats requests on schedule.

Is it cheaper to remove my data myself?

Yes, in money, and it can work better. Consumer Reports found manual opt-outs removed 70% of listings within a week, more than any paid service, though that group was small. The cost is time: you repeat requests for each site, and brokers re-list data. A service saves hours and repeats requests on a schedule.

Does DeleteMe cover more brokers than Incogni?

On paper, yes: DeleteMe lists 969 to 976 brokers against Incogni’s 420+. In practice, DeleteMe’s standard plan automates about 86 to 101 of them and handles the rest through 40 custom requests a year. Incogni automates 420+ on its Standard plan. Compare the automated count, not the headline number.

Scroll to Top