MemberPress vs Paid Memberships Pro vs WishList Member shown as a vault door with a price sticker, an open padlock on a gift box, and a membership card with a calendar.

MemberPress vs Paid Memberships Pro vs WishList Member: Best WordPress Membership Plugin for Creators

You have an audience, and you want to charge for the best of what you publish. Choosing between MemberPress vs Paid Memberships Pro vs WishList Member is the usual first step. The prices on their pages are not the prices you will pay in year two.

A membership plugin locks content behind a login, takes recurring payments, and manages who has access. Prices changed in 2026. MemberPress replaced its old plans with Launch, Growth, and Scale, and its cheapest plan now takes 4.9% of every payment. WishList Member is owned by Caseproof, the same company that makes MemberPress, so two of these three plugins are siblings.

I tested Paid Memberships Pro for 30 days, building the same paid membership on a fresh WordPress install with a protected post, a checkout page, and a Stripe test payment. I reviewed MemberPress and WishList Member through their documentation, pricing pages, and refund terms, since neither lists a free trial. Here is the honest comparison, including the catch most creators miss: MemberPress and WishList Member both charge half price in year one and full price at renewal. Before configuring membership checkout flows, ensure you compare the best online payment processors for small business to minimize transaction fees.

How We Tested

I scored each plugin on five criteria:

  1. Setup time: how quickly a fresh WordPress site gets a working paid membership.
  2. Content protection and member management: how easily you restrict posts, pages, and files by level.
  3. Payments and transaction fees: which gateways each plan supports and what each vendor takes per payment.
  4. Pricing and three-year cost: the first-year price, the renewal price, and the total after 36 months.
  5. Creator features: courses, content dripping, affiliate tools, and integrations.

MemberPress Review: Polished All-in-One With a Renewal Catch

  • Free plan: No free version or trial; 14-day money-back guarantee
  • Starting price: $199.50 in year one, then $399/year (Launch), plus 4.9% of every payment on Launch
  • Best plan for most users: Growth ($349.50 in year one, $699/year at renewal, no per-payment fee)
  • Platforms: WordPress plugin
  • Affiliate program: Yes, 25% commission on the first sale for each referred customer, 60-day cookie

MemberPress is the best-known WordPress membership plugin. Caseproof makes it, and Caseproof also owns WishList Member. In 2026, it replaced its Basic, Plus, and Pro plans with Launch, Growth, and Scale, so many older reviews quote prices you can no longer buy.

What MemberPress does best

MemberPress puts the core creator toolkit in every plan. Launch includes unlimited members, unlimited courses and lessons, content protection, coupons, and a drag-and-drop curriculum builder. That is enough to sell a course from your own domain without a separate LMS plugin. Course creators hosting heavy video content should also evaluate secure video hosting platforms for course creators alongside their membership plugin.

Growth adds PayPal, Square, manual payments, and content dripping, and it charges no per-payment fee. Scale adds Authorize.net, order bumps, Zapier, and a bundled Easy Affiliate license, which MemberPress sells separately at $499 a year. If you plan to run your own affiliate program, that bundle matters.

Where MemberPress falls short

The cheapest plan takes a cut of your sales. Launch charges 4.9% of every successful payment on top of Stripe’s 2.9% plus $0.30, and it supports Stripe only. On a $29 monthly membership, MemberPress keeps about $1.42, and Stripe keeps about $1.14. One review found the percentage only inside a collapsed FAQ at the bottom of the pricing page, not on the plan card. If handling global sales taxes across membership plans feels overwhelming, consider dedicated merchant of record platforms for digital products instead.

Every plan covers one site. Extra activations cost $69 a year each, up to 15, and WordPress Multisite is not officially supported. First-year prices are half off, then renewals double to $399, $699, and $999. There is no free version and no trial, only a 14-day money-back guarantee.

A $29 membership payment split on MemberPress Launch: about $1.42 to MemberPress, $1.14 to Stripe, with a one-site limit and a $69 extra-site fee.

MemberPress pricing

PlanFirst yearRenewalFee per paymentWhat you get
Launch$199.50$399/year4.9%Stripe only; unlimited members, courses, content protection, coupons; 1 site
Growth$349.50$699/yearNoneAdds PayPal, Square, manual payments, content dripping; 1 site
Scale$499.50$999/yearNoneAdds Authorize.net, order bumps, Zapier, bundled Easy Affiliate; 1 site
Extra sites$69/year each$69/year eachNot applicableUp to 15 extra activations

MemberPress: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Courses, content protection, and coupons on every plan.
  • Growth and Scale charge no per-payment fee.
  • Easy Affiliate is bundled with Scale.
  • 14-day money-back guarantee.

Cons:

  • Launch takes 4.9% of every payment and supports Stripe only.
  • First-year prices are half off, and renewals double.
  • Every plan covers one site, and extra sites cost $69 a year.
  • No free version or trial.

Rating: 4.2 / 5, complete and capable, but the renewal doubling and Launch’s fee reduce its value.

Paid Memberships Pro Review: Free to Start, With a Fee to Watch

  • Free plan: Yes, a free open-source core with no site limit
  • Starting price: $0 (Standard is $499/year or $49/month)
  • Best plan for most users: The free core with your own Stripe keys, or Standard if you want premium add-ons
  • Platforms: WordPress plugin; Max plans add managed hosting
  • Affiliate program: Yes, application required, flat commission of up to $200 per full-priced sale, 90-day cookie, none on renewals

Paid Memberships Pro, or PMPro, is an open-source membership plugin from Stranger Studios. The core is free and GPL-licensed. Paid plans add premium add-ons, updates, and support, and the Max tiers add managed hosting.

What Paid Memberships Pro does best

The free core covers a lot. It includes unlimited members and levels, recurring subscriptions, Stripe and PayPal gateways, and more than 30 free add-ons. You can validate a membership idea without paying a license fee. It also runs on unlimited sites, which suits anyone building sites for clients. When managing user logins and memberships, you should also implement reliable cookie consent and privacy compliance tools to ensure full data protection.

For WordPress developers, the useful detail is that the Stripe fee is documented and avoidable. PMPro says its 2% application fee does not apply to sites that use their own Stripe API keys or hold an active paid license. The paid price also stays the same every year, with no renewal jump.

Where Paid Memberships Pro falls short

Free has a catch. Connect Stripe through PMPro’s built-in Stripe Connect button without an active license, and PMPro adds a 2% application fee to every payment, paid to its developer. One review notes the pricing page does not mention it. Stripe also charges an extra 0.7% on recurring payments that use its Billing API, according to PMPro’s documentation.

The paid entry is the highest of the three. Standard costs $499 a year, or $49 a month, for one site. Older reviews quote $347 or $174 for Standard, and those figures are retired. PMPro describes the Max plans as managed hosting plus implementation, so they are hosting purchases, not just bigger license keys.

Forked path showing Paid Memberships Pro’s free core, a 2% fee through Stripe Connect without a licence, and no fee with your own Stripe API keys.

Paid Memberships Pro pricing

PlanPriceWhat you get
Free$0Core plugin, unlimited members, levels, and sites, Stripe and PayPal, 30+ free add-ons; 2% fee on Stripe Connect without a license
Standard$49/month or $499/yearOne-site license, premium add-ons, updates, support; no application fee
Max$99/month or $999/yearManaged hosting, security, and done-for-you development
Max 2x$299/month or $2,999/yearLarger managed plan
Stripe processing2.9% + $0.30, plus 0.7% on recurring paymentsPaid to Stripe, not to PMPro

Paid Memberships Pro: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Free core with unlimited members, levels, and sites.
  • Stripe and PayPal gateways on the free version.
  • No application fee with your own Stripe keys or an active license.
  • The same price every year, with no renewal doubling.

Cons:

  • 2% Stripe Connect fee on the free version without a license.
  • Standard at $499 a year is the highest paid entry price.
  • Premium add-ons require a paid license.
  • Older reviews quote retired prices.

Rating: 4.6 / 5, the best starting point for most creators.

WishList Member Review: Lowest Paid Entry Price, Same Renewal Catch

  • Free plan: No free plan and no confirmed free trial
  • Starting price: $149.50 in year one, then $299/year (Basic)
  • Best plan for most users: Basic for one site; Plus for two sites and gamification
  • Platforms: WordPress plugin
  • Affiliate program: Yes, application-based Affiliate and Partnership Program; commission rate unconfirmed

WishList Member is a WordPress membership plugin that includes CourseCure, an LMS plugin, in its plans. Caseproof acquired its parent company, WishList Products, on May 18, 2023, and said it would keep WishList Member as a standalone product. That makes it a sibling of MemberPress.

What WishList Member does best

Basic is the cheapest paid plan of the three, at $149.50 in year one. It includes unlimited members, memberships, and upgrade paths, unlimited content protection rules, drip and scheduled content, Stripe, PayPal, and eWay, and CourseCure. Pay Per Post lets you sell single articles, which suits bloggers who monetize individual pieces.

Higher plans add sites and tools. Plus covers two sites and adds CourseCure gamification with badges and points. Pro covers five sites and adds team accounts, file and folder protection, and quizzes. The five-site Pro plan costs $349.50 in year one, which helps freelancers building for clients.

Where WishList Member falls short

The renewal is the catch. Basic jumps from $149.50 to $299 after year one, Plus from $249.50 to $499, and Pro from $349.50 to $699. WishList Member carries the same introductory-pricing footnote as MemberPress, and renewals are billed at the full price. Budget for the second year, not the first.

The roadmap sits with a parent that also sells MemberPress. Caseproof said it would fold CourseCure into WishList Member, but there is no public roadmap beyond that. A rival plugin vendor argues its standalone price is hard to justify next to MemberPress or PMPro, so treat that as a competitor’s view. There is no free version or confirmed trial, so test the refund window early.

WishList Member renewal prices doubling, Basic $149.50 to $299, Plus $249.50 to $499, Pro $349.50 to $699, beside the Caseproof link to MemberPress.

WishList Member pricing

PlanFirst yearRenewalSitesWhat you get
Basic$149.50$299/year1Unlimited members and protection rules, drip content, CourseCure, Stripe, PayPal, eWay
Plus$249.50$499/year2Adds CourseCure gamification, webinar integrations, 30+ integrations, priority support
Pro$349.50$699/year5Adds team accounts, file and folder protection, quizzes, WooCommerce, Zoom, Zapier
Elite$899Listed at $899/year5Adds Keap and Recurly integrations

WishList Member: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Lowest paid entry price at $149.50 in year one.
  • Drip content, PayPal, and CourseCure included in Basic.
  • Pay-per-post for selling single articles.
  • Five-site Pro plan suits client work.

Cons:

  • Renewals double to $299, $499, and $699.
  • Basic covers one site.
  • Owned by the same company as MemberPress.
  • No free version or confirmed trial.

Rating: 4.0 / 5, the cheapest paid entry, held back by the renewal jump.

Two line charts showing MemberPress Growth beating Launch above about $3,061 a year in payments in year one and about $6,122 a year at renewal.

Head-to-Head Comparison Table

FeatureMemberPressPaid Memberships ProWishList Member
Free versionNoYes, with unlimited sitesNo
First-year price$199.50 (Launch)$0 free, or $499 (Standard)$149.50 (Basic)
Renewal price$399 (Launch)$499 (Standard)$299 (Basic)
Fee per payment4.9% on Launch, none above2% on free Stripe Connect, none with own keysNone
Payment methods, entry planStripe onlyStripe and PayPalStripe, PayPal, eWay
Sites included1Unlimited free, 1 on Standard1 on Basic
CoursesBuilt in on every planAdd-ons and integrationsCourseCure included
Three-year cost, entry plan$997.50 plus 4.9% fee$0 free, or $1,497$747.50
OwnerCaseproofStranger StudiosCaseproof
Best forCreators selling coursesMost creators starting outOne-site budget builds
Rating4.2 / 54.6 / 54.0 / 5

Which Should You Choose?

The right plugin depends on your budget, your payment setup, and how many sites you run.

  • Choose Paid Memberships Pro if you want a free start and are comfortable adding your own Stripe API keys to avoid the 2% fee. Move to Standard when you need premium add-ons.
  • Choose MemberPress if you want built-in courses and a complete setup, and you will take Growth at $349.50 rather than Launch.
  • Choose WishList Member if you want the lowest paid entry price with PayPal, content dripping, and CourseCure for one site.
Decision flowchart for choosing a WordPress membership plugin: free start to Paid Memberships Pro, courses to MemberPress Growth, one-site budget to WishList Basic.

Watch the fee and the renewal

Launch’s cut grows with your revenue. Growth costs $150 more in year one and charges no fee, so it becomes cheaper above about $3,061 a year in payments. Once both plans renew at full price, the gap is $300, and the crossover moves to about $6,122 a year.

The renewal matters as much as the fee. MemberPress and WishList Member both cut the first year in half and bill the second year at full price. PMPro charges the same price every year.

What each costs over three years

Take one site and one plan. WishList Member Basic costs $747.50 over 36 months: $149.50, then $299 twice. MemberPress Launch costs $997.50 on the same pattern ($199.50, then $399 twice), plus 4.9% of every payment. MemberPress Growth costs $1,747.50.

Paid Memberships Pro Standard costs $1,497 over three years at $499 a year, or $0 on the free core with your own Stripe keys. WishList Member Plus costs $1,247.50, and Pro costs $1,747.50. MemberPress Scale costs $2,497.50.

Bar chart of 36-month membership plugin cost: Paid Memberships Pro free $0, WishList Basic $747.50, MemberPress Launch $997.50, Standard $1,497, Growth $1,747.50.

Our Recommendations

  • Solo creator on a budget: Start with the Paid Memberships Pro free core and your own Stripe keys. You pay no license fee and no application fee.
  • Creator selling a course: Use MemberPress Growth. Courses are built in, and Growth removes the 4.9% fee and adds PayPal and content dripping.
  • Blogger selling premium posts: Use WishList Member Basic. Pay Per Post sells single articles, and PayPal and drip content are included.
  • Freelancer building client sites: Use the Paid Memberships Pro free core, which has no site limit, or WishList Member Pro for five sites. MemberPress adds $69 a year for each extra site.
  • Creator who wants hosting handled: Use PMPro Max at $999 a year. It bundles managed hosting and done-for-you development.

WordPress note: Exclude checkout, login, and account pages from page caching and CDN caching, or members may see stale or wrong pages. MemberPress also gives you 21 days to activate a license key before the plugin deactivates.

Final Verdict

Paid Memberships Pro is the best starting point for most creators. The free core covers unlimited members, recurring payments, and Stripe and PayPal, and its fee disappears with your own Stripe keys. MemberPress is the better all-in-one for course sellers, as long as you skip Launch. WishList Member is the cheapest paid option for one site, but it renews at double the first-year price.

In the MemberPress vs Paid Memberships Pro vs WishList Member decision, start free with Paid Memberships Pro and upgrade only when a paid feature earns its cost.

  • Paid Memberships Pro: 4.6 / 5, best free start and the most predictable pricing.
  • MemberPress: 4.2 / 5, best all-in-one for course sellers on Growth or Scale.
  • WishList Member: 4.0 / 5, cheapest paid entry for a single site.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best WordPress membership plugin for creators?

Paid Memberships Pro is the best starting point for most creators. Its free core covers unlimited members, recurring payments, and Stripe and PayPal at $0. MemberPress suits creators who want built-in courses and will pay for Growth. WishList Member is the cheapest paid option for one site.

Does MemberPress charge a transaction fee?

Only on the Launch plan. Launch takes 4.9% of every successful payment on top of your payment processor’s fees. Growth and Scale charge no MemberPress fee. Upgrading removes the fee from future payments but does not refund what you already paid on Launch.

Is Paid Memberships Pro free?

Yes, the core plugin is free and open source, with unlimited members, levels, and sites. One fee applies: connecting Stripe through its Stripe Connect button without an active license adds a 2% application fee. Use your own Stripe API keys to avoid it. Premium add-ons need a paid license.

Do MemberPress and WishList Member renew at full price?

Yes. Both discount the first year by half, then renew at the regular price. MemberPress Launch goes from $199.50 to $399, and WishList Member Basic goes from $149.50 to $299. Paid Memberships Pro charges the same price every year. Budget for the renewal before you buy.

Are MemberPress and WishList Member made by the same company?

Yes. Caseproof, the company behind MemberPress, acquired WishList Products on May 18, 2023. It said it would keep WishList Member as a standalone product and fold the CourseCure LMS into it. Paid Memberships Pro is made by a separate company, Stranger Studios.

Can I use one MemberPress license on more than one site?

No, not without paying more. Every plan includes one site activation. Additional activations cost $69 a year each, up to 15 extra, and WordPress Multisite is not officially supported. Paid Memberships Pro’s free core has no site limit, and WishList Member Pro covers five sites.

Which membership plugin is cheapest over three years?

For one site, Paid Memberships Pro’s free core costs $0 if you use your own Stripe keys. Among paid options, WishList Member Basic costs about $747.50 over three years. MemberPress Launch costs $997.50 plus its 4.9% fee, and PMPro Standard costs $1,497.

Will a membership plugin work with my caching plugin?

Yes, with exclusions. Exclude checkout, login, and account pages from page caching and CDN caching so members never see another person’s page. LiteSpeed Cache and WP Rocket both support URL exclusions. After setup, log in as a test member in a private window and check protected pages.

Scroll to Top